In earlier stages of my life, I would not have subscribed. But at this point, I listen to these guys every day and really only send about $200 a year to the boys in return (couple/few shows and a CD or two). Given the amount of listening I do, I don't think it's unreasonable to pay them $10 a month, so I just signed up. Especially since the sound quality is so much better than the Phish OD app (which is awesome, don't get me wrong!!!). If I can hear Mike's bass clearly, that's worth $10 a month for me. But that's FOR ME. I totally get that others might not be into it. But I agree with someone above who pointed out that subscribers should get webcasts included.